I should really possibly point out that I did not say which technique is proper. Just wanted to give The main reason why They are really distinctive. To help make The 2 solutions equivalent you'll want to visualize investing/borrowing $PnL_1$ at level $r$ so that it stays in the system https://pnl77420.blogolize.com/helping-the-others-realize-the-advantages-of-pnl-73143000